Tuam Herald Newspaper Letter
 (Page 8, February 26th 2004 Edition)
   
Main Text of Tuam Herald Letter  
  Ann Marie Kelly  
 "There is 
NOTHING we can do" 
   local politicians  
| 
       
          From:
          
          William Finnerty
         
        
          To:
          
          
          Prime Minister Bertie Ahern ;
          
          
          President Mary McAleese ;
          
          
          Chief Justice of The Republic of Ireland (Mr. Ronan Keane)
          
         
        
          Cc:
          
          Margot Wallstrom (European Union Environment Commissioner) ;
          
          Commission of the European Communities (Attn. Secretary-General) ;
          Bord 
          Pleanala ;
          
          Self (Hotmail) ;
          
          Self (Eircom) ;
          
          Self (Yahoo) ;
          Sinn Fein 
          Party ;
          
          Labour Party ;
          Green Party 
          (Head Office, Dubilin) ;
          
          Fine Gael Party ;
          Democratic 
          Left Party ;
          
          Progressive Democrats ;
          Fianna 
          Fail Party
         
        
          Sent: Friday, February 27, 2004 12:32 PM 
        
          Subject:
          Sick Dictatorship <<< OR >>> Healthy Democracy 
      
        ----- Original Message -----
       
      
          From:
          
          William Finnerty
         
        
          To:
          
          trabbitt@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          tmchugh@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          tmannion@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          sgavin@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          sconnaughton@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          sbreathnach@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          posullivan@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          pofoighil@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          pmchugh@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          phynes@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          mregan@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          mmullins@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          mloughnane@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          mhoade@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          mgormally@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          mfahy@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          mcunningham@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          mconnolly@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          kquinn@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          jmcdonagh@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          jmcclearn@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          jjoyce@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          jjmannion@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          jcuddy@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ; jconneely@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          connie.nifhatharta@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          twalsh@cllr.galwaycoco.ie ;
          
          Paul Connaughton TD ;
          Joe 
          Callanan TD ;
          
          Paddy McHugh TD ;
          
          Padraic.McCormack T.D. ;
          
          Noel Grealish T.D. ;
          
          Minister Noel Treacy TD ;
          
          Minister Frank Fahey T.D. ;
          
          Michael D Higgins T.D. ;
          Éamon Ó Cuív 
          T.D. ;
          
          Sean O'Neachtain (Member of European Parliament) ;
          
          Joe McCartin (Member of European Parliament) ;
          
          Rosemary Scallon (Member of European Parliament)
         
        
          Cc:
          
          Connacht Tribune Editor (Mr. John Cunningham) ;
          
          Keith Finnegan at Galway Bay FM (local radio) ;
          
          Galway Advertiser Editor (Mr. Declan Varley) ;
          
          Tony Galvin (Award Winning Tuam Herald Journalist) ;
          
          Tuam Herald ;
          
          New Inn AntiDump Internet Group ;
          
          Kilconnell Anti-Dump Internet Group ;
          
          Kilconnell Anti-Dump Group Secretary (Annette Gilchrist) ;
          New Inn 
          Anti-Dump Chairman (Vincent Costello) ;
          
          Self (Yahoo) ;
          
          Self (Eircom) ;
          
          Self (Hotmail) ;
          
          Woodlawn House Preservation Society ;
          
          CelticParty(Yahoo)
         
        
          Sent: Friday, February 27, 2004 8:32 AM 
        
          Subject: 
          "There is NOTHING we can do" ??? 
      
        +++++++++++++++++++++++++ 
      
        An almost identical copy of the 
        "There is nothing we can do" Ann Marie Kelly letter text below 
        has been published on Page 8 of this week's edition of
        The Tuam Herald Newspaper (dated February 26th 
        2004). 
      
        +++++++++++++++++++++++++ 
      
        ----- Original Message -----
         
      
          From:
          
          kellybrendan
         
        
          To:
          
          William Finnerty
         
        
          Sent: Tuesday, February 24, 2004 8:07 PM 
        
          Subject: Fw: Connacht Tribune letter & Bord Pleanala 
          information  
      
        ----- Original Message -----
         
      
          From:
          
          kellybrendan
         
        
          To:
          
          news@connacht-tribune.ie ;
          
          dvarley@galwayadvertiser.ie ;
          
          info@galwayindependent.com ;
          
          news@irelandonsunday.com ;
          
          info@emigrant.ie ;
          
          andrea.grainger@examiner.ie ;
          info@unison.ie 
          ; 
          news@gbfm.galway.net ;
          sbpost@iol.ie 
          ; nuacht@tg4.ie 
          ;
          
          lettersed@irish-times.ie ;
          
          editor@tuamherald.ie ;
          
          tgalvin@tuamherald.ie ;
          
          02586592 ;
          
          kellybrendan@eircom.net
         
        
          Sent: Monday, February 23, 2004 11:06 PM 
        
          Subject: Fw: Connacht Tribune letter & Bord Pleanala 
          information 
      
          Dear Editor, 
      
          I feel that the letter by Mr Kilgannon on last week's 
          Connacht Tribune should not go unchallenged.  
        
          While I fully agree with the 4 points made by Mr 
          Kilgannon and his calling for an investigation into the activities of 
          Galway County Council, I would like to point out that he appears to 
          have conveniently missed out on some other very important 
          issues raised at the public meeting in Ballyfa on February 9th (which 
          we both attended).   
        1) In recent weeks it has emerged that Sam Shires Recycling company offered to finance, build, and run a recycling plant which did not require the use of either superdumps or incinerators. As Galway County Councillors have been slyly aware of all along it seems, this offer was rejected in July 2001 - well over 2 years ago now - by the Galway County Council Manager (Mr. Donal O'Donohue) and his management team. Despite Minister Noel Tracy's shoddy attempts to cover bad reasons with good at Ballyfa, I can find no genuinely good reason at all for the rejection of this offer. 
          2) As I pointed out at the Ballyfa 
          meeting, and allowing for the fact I am a law student, there is a very 
          strong possibility that Waste Management (Amendment) Act 2002 
          is unconstitutional.  The content of 
          Article 28A (Item 1) of our written Constitution reads as follows:  " 
          The State recognises the role of local government in providing a forum 
          for the democratic representation of local communities, in exercising 
          and performing at local level powers and functions conferred by law 
          and in promoting by its initiatives the interests of such communities. 
          "
          
           
        
      
            In my opinion nothing could be clearer than the Article 28A 
            statement above, and to remove the decision making powers in regard 
            to superdumps from the elected representatives of local communities 
            such as Kilconnell and New Inn is nothing short of dictatorship by 
            central government: and wholly in breach of our Constitution.
           
          
            3) Though it was not mentioned at the Ballyfa 
            meeting, it is nevertheless common knowledge that a bribe offer of 
            €50,000 is not being investigated even 
            though efforts to do so have been made in the Dail by the Leader of 
            the Green Party, Deputy Trevor Sargent T.D.  How come it was not any 
            of the east Galway TDs who raised this extremely serious matter in 
            the Dail? 
           
          
            Mr Kilgannon is canvassing on behalf of Fine Gael, who are supposed 
            to be the opposition party.  As such, they should have demanded 
            that President Mary McAleese tested the constitutionality of Waste 
            Management (Amendment) Act 2002 by referring the matter to the 
            Supreme Court - as is normal in cases where there is doubt.  As the 
            present "guardian" of the Republic of Ireland Constitution, that is 
            (in my view) by far the most important responsibility of President 
            Mary McAleese.  And, as recent legal events connected with the 
            Carraigmines Campaigners (M50 Motorway) suggest, at least one other 
            law may have been given the go-ahead under President McAleese's 
            "guardianship" which the Supreme Court later rejected as 
            "unconstitutional". 
          
            It should also be pointed out, and as became clear yet again at the 
            Ballyfa meeting, that FF and FG now appear to be singing from the 
            exact same "Hymn Book" when it comes to the protection of local 
            community interests regarding superdumps.  "There is nothing 
            we can do" is still the central theme of their very vocal 
            performance, and this six-word mantra was repeated over and over 
            again in Ballyfa, as it has been since Fianna Fail Deputies Treacy 
            and Kitt betrayed our communities by voting in favour of Waste 
            Management (Amendment) Act 2002 in the Dail nearly two years ago.  
            Who was it once said: 
              "If you repeat a lie often 
            enough, people will believe it." ?   
          
            The truth is, and as I pointed out in Ballyfa, the Galway County 
            Councillors could - and should (in my view) - all resign on the 
            grounds that they no longer have the legal power they need to do 
            their jobs responsibly under the terms of Article 28A of our written 
            Constitution. 
          
            As I stated in Ballyfa, I see the ongoing "There is nothing we can 
            do" stance of our elected local government representatives as an 
            absolute disgrace.
           
          
            Instead of resigning after they were made powerless to protect the 
            environment (in the interests of the local communities who elected 
            them), the Galway County Councillors are instead choosing to keep on 
            attending County Council meetings (at the expense of the taxpayer) 
            which they can now have no meaningful input to.  Much more 
            irritating from the viewpoint of the public, is that the FF and FG 
            councillors keep on turning up at anti dump meetings in places such 
            as Ballyfa and Kilconnell - for no purpose, it seems, other than 
            to placate and to appease gullible members of the public on behalf 
            of their tyrannous puppet-masters in Dublin (and elsewhere perhaps), 
            and to try and get votes for themselves in the next election. 
          
            I would ask why is Mr Kilgannon and his other companions in FF and 
            FG seeking election to a forum which gives them no worthwhile say in 
            local community matters?  It wouldn't by any chance, would it, have 
            anything to do with the many thousands of very easy-to-come-by EUROS 
            they collect in expenses generated for them by the large numbers of 
            hard working taxpayers who are thoroughly sick and tired of 
            listening to them (and their false mantras)?  
          
            Is Mise le Meas, 
          
            Ann Marie Kelly 
          
            Killaan, 
          
            Woodlawn, 
          
            Ballinasloe, 
          
            Co. Galway. 
          
            +++++++++++++++++++++++++ 
          
            
              Which direction from here?  
          
                   
              
             Sicker Dictatorship
             <<<  OR  >>>
             Healthier Democracy 
             
          
            
              Who decides?  
          
                   
              
             Elitist Cliques
             <<<  OR  >>>
             The People   
          
            Bord Pleanala Appeal (re 
            planned superdump for Kilconnell): 
          http://www.finnachta.com/BordPleanalaAppeal.htm 
            +++++++++++++++++++++++++ 
          
        End Yahoo! Groups Links 
  | 
      ||
| 
       Recycling offer rejected. Why? Ann Marie Kelly's letter to The Galway Advertiser (Page 24, February 19th 2004)  | 
| 
 | 
    
      
  | 
    ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
      
  | 
| 
       PAGE HISTORY:  | 
Home Page >>> www.finnachta.com <<< Home Page